Skip to content

Ferrari's peace is untested, but Racing Bulls and Williams protected what matters

Ferrari's Brazil truce, Norris's São Paulo win, Racing Bulls keeping Lawson, Audi's Tsunoda appeal and Williams' Friday test plan.

The photo from our story: Ferrari's peace is untested, but Racing Bulls and Williams protected what matters
Photo: Race Service for Ferrari Spa, CC BY-SA 4.0

Ferrari's calm in Brazil came with nothing to fight over

Ferrari's Brazil truce tells us almost nothing. Team principal Fred Vasseur says Lewis Hamilton and Charles Leclerc "left my room joking together" after a private meeting to clear the air, and on the day the peace held. Damon Hill, the 1996 champion, isn't convinced. In comments reported by Motorsport.com, Hill argued that Ferrari are hiding a rift rather than healing one, and The Race made a similar case, saying real tension between the pair remains. Neither side can prove its version from outside the garage.

The trouble with Brazil is what was at stake. After their run-in in Mexico cost Ferrari a win, both drivers followed team orders in São Paulo and left each other plenty of room. That is easy when the scrap is only ever for minor points, never a win or a podium, which is all Interlagos offered them. Mexico was a different thing entirely, because a victory was there for the taking and they lost it.

Vasseur seems to know it. He admits the two races can't be compared, and that all he can do is hope the calm lasts. It's an honest answer, but hope isn't a plan.

Carlos Sainz has seen this before. Asked about Leclerc, he argued that two strong drivers at the front always end up in trouble once wins are involved, and pointed to Mercedes and to McLaren in recent years. Two good drivers and a win to share out doesn't make a law of the sport, but it does make a pattern.

The real test comes when Ferrari are fighting for wins again, whether in Las Vegas, Qatar or Abu Dhabi. A meeting can't decide who gives way when a victory is in play, and Ferrari should settle that order before Las Vegas, given Mexico has already cost them one. Until there's a genuine result to fight over, we're treating the truce as unproven.

Norris made a changeable São Paulo look routine

Brazil did have a winner, though, and Lando Norris made it look like a champion's job. He won in São Paulo with the weather turning and never wobbled. Mixed conditions are about as hard as racing gets, because every lap hands a driver another chance to slip, and one slip can end the race. There's nowhere to hide on a day like that. Norris took none of those chances, and there's no error to point to, which is rare in conditions like those.

The weekend had been awkward from the start. Qualifying was difficult for everyone, and in Q1 the opening laps brought heavy aquaplaning that tripped up several of the grid's less experienced drivers. All of that happened before the race had even begun.

McLaren handled the whole thing better than anyone. As Palmer observed on formula1.com, the team came out on top in nearly every test the Brazilian weekend set them. That is team work as much as driver work, and it matters, because driver and team got the weekend right from the first session to the flag. It also means this was no fluke.

Palmer ranks the win right up there among Norris's best, and we'd put it there too. Raw pace wins a dry race, but judgement wins days like this one, and the way Norris won matters as much as the result. This is how an outgoing champion shows why he held the title, and it's the race we'd show any sceptic.

Racing Bulls put their own season ahead of the pipeline

Racing Bulls have kept Liam Lawson and Arvid Lindblad for 2027. On this year's form there is no sporting case for anything else. Lawson has had a strong season, and dropping him would have thrown away the team's momentum. Lindblad stays too, still a rookie, and keeping both lets the team plan next year around what is already working. A settled line-up is worth more to a team than a gamble.

Red Bull chose against what would have been a huge driver sacking. The swap on the table was Tsolov for Lawson, which would have meant dropping the driver who is delivering to bring in someone new, all to help a different team. It would have given up the team's present for the senior Red Bull team's future. In other words, it would have served Red Bull more than Racing Bulls, and giving up your own present for someone else's future is a hard sell.

The Race noted that Racing Bulls are now a multi-billion dollar entity, and an outfit of that size has interests of its own. There was a time when the team existed to bring young drivers through. With Marko no longer in charge, developing young talent isn't the only goal any more, or even the main one, and this contract backs that up. It reads like a team that have decided what they want to be.

Racing Bulls were right to keep Lawson on results, which is the cleanest way to earn a seat. Having put their own season ahead of Red Bull's next prospect once, we expect them to keep choosing that way.

Audi's Monza appeal rests on who caused the extra lap

Audi want Yuki Tsunoda penalised for Monza, and it is a long shot. The International Court of Appeal will hear the case on 25 November, and it turns on a single question: who caused the extra formation lap at the Italian Grand Prix?

The rule itself is blunt. Under Article B5.9.4 of the sporting regulations, a driver who causes an extra formation lap has to start from the end of the pit lane, and an unserved stop-and-go becomes a 30-second penalty after the race. The idea behind it is simple: whoever causes the problem pays for it. Tsunoda finished 10th, seven seconds clear of Gabriel Bortoleto. If Audi's argument holds, Tsunoda drops to 15th and their driver moves up to tenth, worth a point.

Tsunoda was standing in for Lawson at Monza. At the restart after a red flag on 6 September, he was due to line up 14th but first aimed at the 15th-place slot by mistake, then swung right at the last moment. He stopped inside his own box, but his Racing Bulls car sat at an angle. Race director Rui Marques wasn't happy to start with the car parked like that, so he ordered another formation lap.

That decision is the hinge of the whole case, because the rule asks who caused the lap. Racing Bulls argued that Tsunoda stayed within his box and affected nobody else. The stewards accepted that, found the extra lap came from Marques's own choice rather than from the driver, and took no further action. Audi see Tsunoda as the trigger, and on 9 September they lodged their appeal over how the rule was applied.

A finding like that is hard to unpick, because a different reading of the rule is not a different set of facts, and Audi need more than a new reading to move it. The court isn't a rubber stamp, though. In September it reinstated two penalties given to Pierre Gasly at Monaco and later rescinded. Even so, we'd back the stewards, and Tsunoda's result looks safe.

Williams have given up their Fridays for the 2027 car

Williams have turned both their race drivers into Friday test drivers, and with this year's car near its limit it is the best use of them. The Race went as far as calling Sainz and Alex Albon perhaps the most overqualified test drivers anywhere. The two run very different programmes in Friday practice, both of it test-style work for next year's car.

Sainz describes it as correlation work, comparing what the car does on track with what it does in the simulator. He adds that it also builds his knowledge of the car and the team, and his feel for how big the changes are. Albon explains that the factory simulator is now given almost entirely to next year's car, so Fridays are where the real car checks that work. That link between the track and the factory is what makes the trade worth it.

The current car's ceiling is clear and fixed, so giving up a polished Friday costs little. It arrived late in Bahrain, overweight and slow. The Baku upgrade brought it down to the weight limit, but it was mostly an investment in next year, and because the chassis carries over, that work carries into the new car. That car is where Williams' future gets decided.

The standings explain the urgency. Williams sit ninth of 11 teams on points, ahead of only Aston Martin and Cadillac on points and on single-lap pace, and they were the only team to miss January's Barcelona shakedown. From a start like that, spending a Friday polishing a weekend that can't be saved is a poor trade, and data for next year is worth more than a few places this weekend. The plan only fails if the 2027 car falls short, and Sainz admits that is his biggest concern.

The first of this week's choices to be tested in a courtroom rather than on track comes soon. Audi's appeal will be heard at the FIA's headquarters in Paris on 25 November, behind closed doors at the FIA's request, with a point for Bortoleto riding on the outcome.

Sources

  1. PALMER: Why Norris’ Sao Paulo victory was one of his best ever wins (opens in a new tab), Formula 1
  2. Why Williams has turned Sainz and Albon into test drivers (opens in a new tab), The Race
  3. Court of Appeal to hear Audi’s case over Tsunoda decision on November 25th | Formula 1 (opens in a new tab), RaceFans
  4. Damon Hill: Ferrari has a “political problem” as Lewis Hamilton “rebuilt himself” (opens in a new tab), Motorsport.com
  5. Hearing set for Audi Tsunoda appeal (opens in a new tab), The Race
  6. Ferrari's Leclerc-Hamilton problem is far from solved (opens in a new tab), The Race
  7. Our verdict on Lawson earning a 2027 F1 extension (opens in a new tab), The Race

Share this story

All stories

The race hub

Follow the Las Vegas Grand Prix live

Every car on the track map, the timing tower, race control and our updates as it happens. No subscription, no app.

Practice 1 Fri 20 November, 00:30 GMT